Duration of status is back — or, more precisely, it never left. On November 16, 2026, Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV of the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts vacated the DHS final rule that would have replaced “duration of status” (D/S) with fixed periods of admission for F-1 students, J-1 exchange visitors, and I visa foreign media representatives.
The ruling converts the court’s September preliminary injunction into a final judgment. The rule, which never took effect, is now set aside.
Background: What the Rule Would Have Done
As we reported in July, DHS published the final rule on July 17, 2026, with an effective date of September 15, 2026. Its key provisions would have:
- Replaced D/S with a fixed admission end date tied to the program dates on the Form I-20 or DS-2019, capped at four years
- Required an extension of stay (EOS) filed with USCIS to remain beyond that date, with no appeal from a denial
- Shortened the F-1 post-completion grace period from 60 days to 30 days
- Restricted F-1 transfers and changes in educational objective, and capped language training at 24 months
- Limited F-2 and J-2 dependents to the principal’s authorized period
We recommended that HR and global mobility teams audit their F-1 and J-1 populations, flag programs longer than four years, confirm their systems could track fixed end dates, and build EOS deadlines into onboarding workflows.
On September 14, one day before the effective date, the court postponed the rule. The government appealed that preliminary injunction to the First Circuit, where the appeal remains pending.
The Court’s Decision
The court granted summary judgment to the plaintiffs, a coalition of higher education associations and labor unions, on two independent grounds.
The rule is arbitrary and capricious. The court adopted its September findings that DHS failed to weigh costs and benefits, that its fraud and national security rationales did not support the rule, that it ignored less burdensome alternatives, and that it did not adequately respond to significant comments. In that earlier order, the court called the government’s justification “exceptionally weak.” The court added that DHS never explained why an unreviewable, discretionary extension process would catch fraud better than the existing Student and Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS), which already requires schools and sponsors to report extensively on each student and exchange visitor.
The rule exceeds DHS’s statutory authority. The INA defines F-1 students as bona fide students pursuing a full course of study. The court held that DHS may set reasonable times and conditions of stay, but may not bar students from Ph.D.-length programs, joint degrees, changes in concentration, or a second degree at the same level. In the court’s words, “DHS is seeking to prevent or discourage the very activity — providing educational opportunities for foreign students in the United States — that Congress sought to permit and encourage.”
Vacatur, not remand. DHS asked the court to send the rule back to the agency without vacating it. The court declined, noting that the D/S framework has existed for decades and the rule never took effect.
What This Means Now
For now, the pre-rule framework governs. F-1 students and J-1 exchange visitors continue to be admitted for duration of status, and the provisions we flagged in July do not apply:
- No fixed admission end date and no four-year cap
- No extension of stay filing with USCIS to continue a program
- The F-1 post-completion grace period remains 60 days
- No new restrictions on transfers, changes in educational objective, or language training
- F-2 and J-2 dependents remain tied to the principal’s D/S
- OPT and STEM OPT continue under existing rules, without the new EOS overlay
This is not necessarily the last word. The government has already appealed the preliminary injunction and will very likely appeal the final judgment to the First Circuit. DHS could also seek a stay pending appeal or start a new rulemaking that tries to address the court’s concerns.
Recommended Actions for HR and Mobility Teams
The preparation many employers did over the summer still has value. We recommend the following:
- Keep your F-1 and J-1 audit current. Maintain the inventory of I-20 and DS-2019 program end dates you built for the rule. It remains the best tool for planning OPT, STEM OPT, and H-1B cap timing, and it positions you to move quickly if the rule returns.
- Stand down EOS workflows, but don’t delete them. Remove EOS deadlines from active onboarding and renewal processes so employees are not told to file applications that are no longer required. Archive the workflows and system fields rather than dismantling them.
- Correct any employee communications. If you told F-1 or J-1 employees about fixed admission dates, the 30-day grace period, or EOS filings, send a short update confirming that D/S remains in place.
- Monitor the appeal. Watch for a First Circuit appeal of the final judgment, any stay request, and any new DHS proposal on fixed admission periods.
Meltzer Hellrung will continue to track this litigation and will update clients as the appeal proceeds. For guidance on your F-1 or J-1 population, contact your Meltzer Hellrung attorney.